This page is part of the portfolio of urbis user Russell_Parkway, which lists reviews they have completed which have been revealed.
Reviews
I was confused over the too too strong criteria. My intention was to express that it wasn't. The story sounds interesting, I'm curious to know what happens next. The major weakness was clarity. "In the foyer, I pull from the flask in my black leather jacket and kill her husband, home early from another late “meeting”." This is an example of a sentence that needs to be revised and rewritten. What was it that he pulled from the flask? A gun? If this is an urban expression, then readers from oth...
Wow. I'm hooked to see what happens next. I have a feeling that this will be a good story. Thanks for the read. Now for my suggestions. I noticed that Talia has some voices in her head. I believe the proper way to do this would be to write each thought dialogue in italics the same way that you would if it were speech--with or without quotation marks, according to the Chicago Manual of Style, 15th Edition. I was confused at first, but I understood what you did with the underlining of Talia's t...
What would help you on this is to add some more of the five senses. For example, what did the hallway smell like? Was it dusty, did it smell of mold, or dead corpses. I assumed that she was running, right? Maybe have her sweating and panting, gasping for breath.
One of the more interesting novel treatments I've read. I'm guessing that this story is taken from Sarah's point of view, right? In that case may I suggest you open with Sarah sneaking up on Tiffany Plair as she watches her from behind the tree. Try not to switch POVs so quickly. "Tiffany pondered the idea, then lifted her head and her eyebrows, “Ah! I know…" I would've written: Sarah watched Tiffany raise an eyebrow, as though she pondered the idea. Punctuation "“It’s okay,” Tiffany gave a r...
This is one of the better poems that I've read recently. It was very difficult to find anything wrong with it. Then I reread it and realized that the first sentence is written the wrong way. "Now I know how you must feel." Yet you ask a whole bunch of questions afterwards to the person running on the treadmill. May I suggest you write the first sentence in the form of a question so that it is less contradictory to the rest of the poem which is beautifully written. How do you really feel? Are ...
quite whispers. I think you mean quiet whispers. However, if the person's whispering, mentioning that it's quiet is redundant. action's speak louder than word's. Cut out the apostrophes. This is a cliché sentence. Try something else. Throughout you have apostrophes in the wrong places.
It's not a bad intro. Mind you must be a bit more descriptive in some instances. For example in the first paragraph, you wrote: Still, he had things to do today. What things? Go to hockey practice, prepare for an exam? Much more character background would be needed in order for readers to like him so that he does not appear to be too cardboard.
He heard the sound of his bones cracked as he does so.- His bones made their usual cracking sound. Rick is often quite and did not speak much--Rick is often quiet These are some of the many examples of mistakes that will turn off an agent/editor in under twenty seconds considering that most of these are found within the first page. Another area of improvement would be to improve on what all of us writers do in the begining, which is tell instead of showing. For instance: Richard De Arezzo Jr,...
If I were to know why and how the protagonist is sick and why the woman appeared, it would incite me to read a bit more. All it needs is a stronger hook and for it to answer those two questions. Hope that helps.
Overview

