Non-fiction / Cinderella: A Very Old Legend Lives On (Analysis)
Do you remember when and where you first met Cinderella?
That question fetches many answers in 21st century America. But, two problems arise. Many Americans are perpetuating their own cultural myths, simply because they are immigrants here from other cultures. Another complication to the original fairy tale is technology, whether you first became aware of her from television, in the one of the Disney theme parks around the world or in a video game. In that respect, she becomes life imitating magic. Some children may have been lucky enough to have the story read to them.
The universality of the little ash girl who marries a prince is so pervasive in cultures from oral tradition to modern times that it is difficult to ignore.
Perhaps the story is psychologically satisfying, especially for women. It provides a ‘rags to riches plot,’ good triumphing over evil and the celebration of the spiritual/financial union of marriage for the woman. Women, through marriage have traditionally had a profound effect on changing the geography and social systems of cultures.
A Fairytale with a long history
If the Cinderella you know as a storybook character or a theme park princess, that Cinderella “Cendrillon ” is based on French author, Charles Perrault, who wrote the piece in 1697 and added the glass slipper.
The tale has its roots in the Roman myth of Cupid and Psyche. Psyche also has two older sisters and must endure terrible trials to be united with her beloved “prince,” in this case, Cupid.
Historically, women were vastly challenged in many areas, the focus being the fact that marriage was often a survival factor, and a problem when a father had many daughters.
The tale finds its way into a culture’s religious values as well. It may be asked, do religious values find their way into this cultural tale? In Western Culture, the story of Cinderella has been changed. The Church erased any reference to a pagan Roman Myth and depict her as pious and forgiving of her horrible step-sisters.
Prince William of Wales
For royalty, throughout the ages, marriage is an institution. All eyes have now turned to the young Prince of Wales, William. Rumor and paparazzi prevail. And, every woman still marries her “prince.”
The concept of marriage remains, wealth and all good things after marriage and wrong set to right. With more men marrying for financial gain, and gay marriage on the rise, the myth of Cinderella remains socially current, so long as the right person marries the prince(ss).
Disney’s film, “Cinderella III: A Twist in Time,” directed by Frank Nissen seems aptly named. In an effort to make the tale feel “new,” the writers, of which there are five according to the IMdB, offer a reversal of Cinderella’s original fortunes. Giving us a “what-if” senario and a new way for her to overcome the same adversity.
History of a Fairy Tale
Cinderella’s U.S. corporate marketing aside, this tale evolves independently in hundreds of cultures and throughout history.
The Chinese, Native Americans and the Europeans have taken this story and told it based on that culture’s values. Its belief systems, politics, economics and social status are addressed in much different ways from Charles Perrault and Disney World.
“Yeh-Shen,” the Chinese version, may be the earliest known version of the Cinderella story, it is said to predate any western version of the story by almost 1,000 years. The Native American Cinderella theme, “The Rough-Face Girl,” is a story that has remained consistent with the Algonquin Indians for centuries.
What remains constant in each culture’s tale is innocence triumphing over evil by joining with a higher spiritual being. Cinderella marries a prince, who will become king and thus, anointed by God and Church. In “The Rough-faced Girl,” she does ascend this world with a god-like entity. Yeh-Shen passes the princes and simply goes for the king.
In 2005, divorce declined and so did marriage. Many experts agree more couples are simply co-habitating and as a result throwing off the statistics, according to current census. Sources such as major newspapers and TV reporting state that the divorce rate among married couples has declined.
There is no doubt that in the U.S. we are experiencing quite a baby-boom in 2008. All of these little girls are yet to meet Cinderella, let’s hope we are wise enough to preserve the magic for them.
You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.
Reviews
Sort Reviews by Newest | Oldest | Highest Quality | Lowest Quality | Newest Comments |
I found this essay very insightful and allows the reader to learn that there’s history behind classical fairy tales, as you’ve excellently illustrated. Just a few places you need to pay attention to.
“they are immigrants here from other culture.” This sentence doesn’t read clear.
“in the one of the Disney theme parks” I think you meant to write “in one of the Disney theme parks”
”. . .Europeans have taken this story and told it based on that culture’s values” I think you meant to say that ”. . .have taken this story and retold in a way that reflects their own cultural values”
I look forward to reading your other essays. Good luck with them.
- add/view comments (2)
I enjoyed reading this, it was well thought out and brief enough not to bore. Cinderella has always been one of my favorite tales because it always seemed to be an uplifting tale of overcoming adversity while being true to yourself. I think a little more discussion of the morality of Cinderella could have been useful as it is a large part of any fairytale.
Let me first say that there are a few typos and punctuation issues, which threw off the momentum of the piece. One example is “in the one of the Disney theme parks”. I think it was intended to read, “in one of the Disney theme parks”. I also felt that the first three paragraphs were a bit chopping and could use some re-working. Particularly the point about immigrants, etc. Something about it doesn’t quite flow as well as other areas. A little more editing is needed.
I actually found both the style and topic to be engaging. I like the comparisons between fairy tale and our modern Prince William, with rumor and paparazzi prevailing. I think the writing well divided and well researched. I’d even like to see it expanded upon.
Good writing, keep it up!
~Veda
This 36 word review has not been unlocked.
This 42 word review has not been unlocked.
it made alot of sense it made me think about some things i have read in a book recently.
the book is called and the Shofar Blew by Francine Rivers.
very good would ove to read more by you
have a great day
Excellent research into the Cinderella story. Most folk tales have some basis in fact and you have found that fact. Great research into finding a connection and similarities in other cultures. Too many people think that a story like this is only found in their country. Great comparison to the real world.
This 83 word review has not been unlocked.
Showing 1 - 8 of 8
Review item
Add to faves
GENERAL
REVIEW QUEUE
Ratings & Rankings
| Version 2 |
| Version 1 |