Poetry / If These Scars Could Talk (Analysis)

If these scars could talk
what would they say?
Would you hear every word,
or ignore them in every way?
Would you laugh and say “Don’t you cry,
they are your life, no matter how you try.”

If these scars could talk
would they show that I could not.
Could you see the pain I’ve endured,
denied the joy that I am well dued?
Would you smile and say “It doesn’t matter,
it’s not your love that I am after.”

If these scars could talk
would you heed their words?
For their marks upon my skin,
tell of woes you must akin.
Would you frown and turn away,
and tell me “That’s a story for another day.”

You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.

Reviews

Sort Reviews by  Newest |  Oldest |  Highest Quality |  Lowest Quality |  Newest Comments | 

 
KRIS84 avatar General Stranger

July 05, 2008

KRIS84

personal info reviewer stats
KRIS84 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item
This 17 word review has not been unlocked.
LadyCatie avatar General Stranger

May 11, 2008

LadyCatie

personal info reviewer stats
LadyCatie reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

I can relate to this one a lot.  I have several scars from life, physical and emotional.   There are uglier and more visible scars than mine to be sure but few that tell more of a story.  

I think your poem needs tweaking though, there are a couple places where the rhythm falters as either one too many syllables or too few.  

And, in the last stanza, third line from the bottom, I think the word you want is “ken.”   It means understand, empathise with, or the range of understanding.  And it would solve the one too many syllable problem in that line.

Good attempt.   Take some time to tweak it and I’m sure it’ll get as close to perfect as possible.

PawPrintsOfLife avatar General Stranger

May 10, 2008

PawPrintsOfLife

personal info reviewer stats
PawPrintsOfLife reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item
This 226 word review has not been unlocked.
NedR avatar General Stranger

May 10, 2008

NedR

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(1 vote ) personal info reviewer stats
NedR reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

The poem develops well and has an interesting premise, but I feel like sometimes you’re making some awkward contortions to fit the rhyme scheme – for instance, the phrase “you must akin,” doesn’t make any sense to me. I would suggest changing the rhyme scheme, allowing yourself to be a little looser with it, or possibly ditching it entirely.

Wayoflife avatar General Stranger

May 10, 2008

Wayoflife

personal info reviewer stats
Wayoflife reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

I think you have more give with this poem. This is a great start!! I just feel like it’s not finished yet. I Hope you get what I am sayin’

peejie avatar General Stranger

May 09, 2008

peejie

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(1 vote ) personal info reviewer stats
peejie reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Good poem overall, with a couple of possible exceptions.  
Meaning is deep, the flow isn’t bad but in a couple of spots it feels too forced.  

i.e., Could you see the pain I’ve endured,
denied the joy that I am well dued?

and:
For their marks upon my skin,
tell of woes you must akin.

Your meaning is understood but feels coerced.  
I do think that a bit of revision will make this superb.

Good job.

dolphine32781 avatar General Stranger

May 09, 2008

dolphine32781

personal info reviewer stats
dolphine32781 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Everyone can relate to this poem.  We all have scars, whether emotional or physical. People may not always want to hear about our scars, but that’s why we as writers get them out in a different way.  I enjoyed this piece.

Fashico1 avatar General Stranger

May 08, 2008

Fashico1

personal info reviewer stats
Fashico1 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Very good work. i am a little confused as to why you would say “would they show that i could not”.

misslady2006 avatar General Stranger

May 08, 2008

misslady2006

personal info reviewer stats
misslady2006 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Need to look over “would they show that i could not, denied the joy that i am well dued. Something to look over believes it’s better word choices

Showing 1 - 9 of 9

Creator
lavallee773 avatar

lavallee773 Prolific-icon-medium

Age: 28
Loc: Mililani, HI
Gen: M
Last Login: May 21
Item Stats

GENERAL

9 Reviews 0 Comments
Version 1
Latest Activity: 3 months ago

REVIEW QUEUE

Appeared in Queue: 0 Times
Skipped: 2 Times
Large_criteria Ratings & Rankings
Tags

There are no tags for this item.