Short Story / I'd Love to Change the World (Analysis)

Nathan shot upright in bed, wiped the crusty yellow snot from his eyes and paused, listening for the piercing crack that woke him from a dead sleep to repeat.  It had been loud and sudden--that he remembered--but the tingling awareness crawling up his sweat soaked spine was fading fast, and the wild leaps his imagination took seemed less plausible with each red minute that passed on the radio alarm clock teetering on the night table.

Stupid, he told himself.  Gunshots in his trendy downtown neighborhood were few and far between after all.  An abstract reality to be debated late at night on Internet forums and stories to be seen on the nightly news.  Stories of someone else’s tear stained mother crumbling outside her ramshackle home in someone else’s part of the city, but not his.  Never his.

He flopped backward, slinging an arm over his green eyes to block out the sunlight streaming in through a break in the bedroom blinds.  The apartment was quiet.  No sirens.  No screams.  Just a dull murmur from the busy street three stories below.  

He fell asleep.

And then he heard it.  Not a gunshot, but a shrill shout closely followed by several more, not loud enough to decipher, but just loud enough to grate on his nerves.  Nathan waited for the voices to trail off, move down the street and away from his building, but they didn’t.  They grew louder.

Grinding his teeth, Nathan glanced at the alarm clock.  It was three forty-four in the afternoon.  He had drifted off to sleep for less than an hour, and didn’t need to be “up” officially for another three hours, which would have left him thirty minutes to brush his teeth, slap on a semi-clean t-shirt and still make his seven-thirty date.  He was not happy.

He sighed, flung the sheets from his bare legs, leapt out of bed and stomped toward the blinds.  The window thudded against the top frame as he thrust his head outside.

“What the—”  The words died in his throat.  

Wide eyes quickly scanned below, to the right and to the left.  Everywhere Nathan looked people littered the pavement, packed so tightly the gray street looked like an overstuffed sardine can with its contents still flip-flopping and writhing inside.  Homemade banners and signs painted in bright pinks, yellows, red and blue bobbed in the spring breeze.  Voices clamored over each other, trying to be heard in the rising cacophony.  

Nathan slammed the window shut and paused in front of the glass, captivated by his ghostly reflection outlined in the crowd.  After a moment, he spun on his heel, snagged a dingy black shirt dangling from a dresser drawer and strode out his bedroom door.

“George!” he hollered, marching toward his still slumbering roommate sprawled on the living room couch.  “Get the hell up.”  George groaned, rolled onto his side and buried his face in the cushions.  Nathan slapped him across the back of his head.

“Jesus fucking Christ, Hale! What the fuck?”

“You’ve got to see this shit,” he said.  “There are thousands, literally thousands of people on the street,” said Nathan, peeking out the living room blinds.  George ignored him.  “Come on.  Get up and take a look at this. They‘re everywhere.”

“Who cares.”

“You’re not even the slightest bit curious to know why the whole fucking city is on our doorstep?”

George reluctantly sat up and scratched his bare stomach.  “No, not really,” he grumbled, reaching for a PS3 game controller lying on the floor.

“Not at all?”

“Nope.”  

Nathan unlocked the window and held it open.  He wouldn’t have thought it possible, but in the ten minutes since he woke up and made the discovery downstairs, it seemed as if even more people had filtered into the mob.  People were perched on benches and hanging from street lights, cluttering patios and standing atop immobilized cars.

“Will you shut the goddamn window if I look,” George mumbled, coming up behind his roommate.  He backed away and George stuck his head outside.  

Nathan waited, watching for an astonished look to cross his friend’s face--something that would register this as, if nothing else, an abnormal occurrence, but it never came.  After a minute, George dropped the sash and strolled back to the couch, falling back onto the soft cushions and resting his feet on the glass table in front of him.  Lighting a cigarette, George exhaled slowly and said, “Freaks, dykes and fairies--that’s what you woke me up for?”

Nathan didn’t know what to say.  He wasn’t even sure of his own thoughts so he said nothing, choosing instead to watch George as he flipped the television on and restarted his game, staring blindly at the flickering lights.  He could almost hear the crowd amidst the sounds of screeching tires and gunshots booming from the surround sound system.

“I’m gonna go get some coffee,” said Nathan, heading back to his bedroom for a pair of jeans.

“What? Now,” asked George, surprised enough to pause his game. “You’re not going to do anything stupid, are you?” he shouted from the living room.

“No. I’m just going to get some coffee and check things out.  You want anything?”  Nathan slipped on a pair of dirty jeans from the floor and walked back towards the living room.  

“The usual.  Just don’t get involved, Hale,” said George.

“I’m not.”

“Good. Don’t,” said George, eying his friend through a blue cloud of smoke.  “I mean—what the hell do they think they are going to accomplish?”

“I don’t know.  Maybe they just want to do something.  You know—change the world or something like that.”

“Where is the sanity in that?” he said, snuffing his cigarette in an old Burger King wrapper.  “It’s not like anything they do is going to change anything.  This is the way things are, and the way things will always be.  Except downhill—there’s always that.  And come on, who do they think we’re fighting, the man?“ he snorted.  “Too much fucking effort and not enough reward.”

“Where my wallet?”

George waved his hand.  “On the counter, my man.”

“I’ll be back in a bit,” Nathan said.

“Lock the door on your way out.  I don’t want any of those dipshits to come wandering in here when the pigs start ramming their big fat pork sausages up their protesting do-gooder asses.”

Nathan paused, hand on the door.  “Don’t feel like you need to do anything.”

“Trust me, I won’t,” George snorted. “Did you see that sign?  Tax the rich.  Feed the poor.  Till there are no rich no more. Yeah, OK.  I say lay off the burritos and get a job fat fuck and…”  The words trailed off, replaced by the blaring sirens erupting from the restarted game as Nathan clicked the door behind him.

Downstairs, the crowd was even more chaotic than it had appeared from above.   Nathan paused at the glass foyer doorway; hand poised on the latch and contemplated going back.  

Up above, there was safety and security, frozen hot pockets and the comfort of knowing what the day would bring.  Outside bodies churned and writhed against each other like waves in a rocky sea cascading toward land.  It didn’t look violent though, he rationalized.  Adamant, but not violent.  Nathan pushed the door open.

He kept to the sides at first, away from the chanting throng pushing its way down the street, and inched his way along the building walls.  As he made his way down the block, he came across people like him, people he knew who had come from the stores lining the street or the apartments above, standing on the sidelines or peeking behind curtains, watching the crowd before them with perplexed gazes.  Their eyes would meet his, these fellow bystanders, and together for the briefest instant, he’d share a nodding agreement and keep walking, tripping over the crowd that sometimes spilled over.

Nathan didn’t see the guy with the megaphone until he knocked him over and nearly took his head off, jumping up and latching onto the streetlight beside him like a monkey in an urban forest.  People pushed him aside, not even glancing down at him as they continued moving down the street, hands raised and screaming.  Someone stepped on his hand and Nathan groaned, struggling to his feet and trying to pull his weight up by grasping onto the monkey man’s big black boot.

Swinging around with one arm, the monkey man blasted crackling broken rants from the megaphone into Nathan’s upturned face. “Population…breeding!”  Unyielding black eyes glared at him over the megaphone’s vibrating red center and continued without pause. “Nation…bleeding…economy!”  Nathan pushed away from the streetlight, leaving the monkey man to his diatribe, and rubbed his tingling ears.

Life is funny, he thought to himself, pressing against a niche in a nearby building.  The street was complete chaos and yet, the sky above was sunny and brimming with fat white clouds against a pristine blue spring backdrop.  Not the tableau he would have imagined, he thought, swatting a buzzing bee from his sweaty forehead as a pretty young redhead smiled in his direction and passed by, waving a sign above her emblazoned with something about money and monopoly.

He sniffed, pulling the air into his lungs and smelled pungent coffee.  Nathan turned around, saw the big emerald letters above the doorway and realized that he was already at the end of the block.

Someone pushed him and Nathan’s head smashed into the glass, bouncing off the sharp edge of the frame.  Blood poured across his face as he stumbled into the entryway, touching his wet eyebrow.  He slumped to the ground and stared at his bright red fingertips, listening to the shouts from the street in a daze.  World pollution…institution…electrocution—it all blurred in his head.

“Are you OK?” someone asked beside him, reaching out to touch his head.

Nathan turned to the voice.  “I think so,” he said.  

The homeless man examined his head, gently touching the laceration streaming blood across Nathan’s eyes and pursed his wrinkled lips.  “I might have something for it,” he said, digging into a tattered gray satchel slung across his slumped shoulders.  Nathan watched as the man took out and discarded several scraps, before pulling the dull, torn orange beanie off his head and offering it to bleeding young man.

Nathan protested, pushing the man’s cracked and brown hand away. “I can’t.”

“Sure you can,” the man said, stuffing the hat into his hand.  

“Can I give you something for it,” said Nathan, reaching for the wallet in his back pocket. The man grasped his arm, and held it for several long moments, staring at him in earnestness.  Finally, Nathan nodded, understanding and put his wallet back into his pocket.  “Thank you,” he said quietly, pulling the cap over his blonde hair and forehead.

The man slumped back into position, and the two men sat together watching as fists began to swing in the crowd.  A bottle careened against a wall, exploding into a million shards.  Sirens could be heard wailing in the distance, coming closer.

“Black and white, rich or poor, it’s just them and us,” the man whispered.

“Yeah, stop the war!” Nathan shouted, surprised.  The old man turned sharply, and eyed Nathan, who grimaced in embarrassment.

“I bet this isn’t what you came outside for,” the old man said.  “Should have stayed inside.”

“Maybe,” said Nathan.  “But I needed coffee.”

The man snorted.  “Coffee?”

“Yep. I needed to wake up.”

“Well then,” said the man, chuckling.  “It’s a fine time for coffee.”

You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.

Reviews

Sort Reviews by  Newest |  Oldest |  Highest Quality |  Lowest Quality |  Newest Comments | 

 
jen52 avatar General Stranger

July 18, 2008

jen52

personal info reviewer stats
jen52 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Ah, it’s inspirational.  The change is happening in the place where it’s not intended, and that’s a pointed observation that occurs more often than not.  And where the people set out with intent to create change, chaos ensued, as is quite often the case.  

I think there were a couple small issues with mechanics.  There is a point where Nathan says “Where my wallet” and that should be “Where’s my wallet”.

This seems more like an introduction to a longer story, maybe about an unlikely friendship between a young man and an insightful homeless man.  Or maybe the story of the young man’s “awakening” of some sort.  I want to know what happens next.

Thanks for writing!

smitisan avatar General Friend

June 05, 2008

smitisan

personal info reviewer stats
smitisan reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

That’s the question, does anyone know what to do? I think you’ve got a good story here, a metaphor for our situation at present. Nathan, the activist who gets caught up and bloodied in the sweep of history, is a good contrast to George, the cynic in his cocoon. That Nathan bears the name of a Great American Patriot is a slap in the face to those pretend patriots, like George, for whom the status quo is good enough so long as they have their material goods. Likewise the egomaniacal politician who doesn’t see Nate’s situation, only a target for his propaganda, versus the homeless sage. I got lost at the streetlight, though, not sure who it was that got knocked down. I had to backtrack a bit to figure out that the monkey man and the megaphone man were the same. It seemed that Nathan jumped up onto the streetlight, but then there he was on the ground, reaching up for the fellow’s boot. All the pronouns are hard to sort through, but I don’t know how to fix it.  Maybe if the megaphone itself almost took Nate’s head off, and the man behind it, blinded by it, made a grab for the light, knocking Nate down in the process. Other than that, I can’t find any real faults here. I congratulate you.  

abweicher_ian avatar General Stranger

June 03, 2008

abweicher_ian

personal info reviewer stats
abweicher_ian reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

This is the start of something good.  However great the writing is, the story seems inconsistent.  I’m wondering at the end: was someone shot, then a riot broke out?  If so, then why the signs and protest (pretests being organized and all).  The speakerphone man’s words are written to imply fable because they are grouped together.  If you’re just highlighting certain words, then perhaps peppering them through the narration would add to the effect.  I think putting them all together takes from the concept of just this and that; it appears that’s what he’s saying and only what he’s saying.  The spiel about how no one gets shot at around his neighborhood--if it’s just an abstract happenstance before the shooting, then why the apathy to see/experience the tangible manifestation of that abstraction? seems unnatural to me.  I really liked how each of the words seem anchored in the story--if not carefully chosen, then compactly explicit.  However, a little something extra needs to hold it together, I think.  Sort of like reading a report vs. reading an essay.  I can clearly see in my mind’s eye what you’re describing, but I can’t feel it all too well.  Perhaps adding descriptions that are beyond visual?  If you’re sticking to short story format, then it feels like the pace is right, but I think it could use a harder punch or more traces of background and retrospection.  
Anyway… I liked this, and would like to read more.

aarondodd avatar General Stranger

June 02, 2008

aarondodd

personal info reviewer stats
aarondodd reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Hello.

I found this piece to be interesting, but I felt that its strengths were more in the beginning.  The descriptions of Nathan waking up were very vivid.  His reactions were exactly how I would react to be awakened in the afteroon while trying to nap.  The waiting for people’s voices to receed as they past exactly describes what its like to be interrupted by someone being loud outside the window.  the piece seemed to lose these vivid descriptions as it went on.

George, I felt, was a good contrast to Nate in terms of his reaction (Nathan was curious, intrigued, and I inferred somewhat sympathetic to the crowd whereas George was apathetic, even hostile).  However, after reading the piece I felt as though George ended up being a mere plot device to speak the words “Freaks, dykes and fairies”.  What I mean is once Nathan left the apartment, George is gone from the piece, yet about one-third of the piece was spent with George involved.

Before I continue, while I recognize that “Freaks, dykes and fairies” is part of a song quote, as it was written here I felt it to be slightly offensive.  This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, as you show George to be pretty much a bigoted person (“I say lay off the burritos and get a job fat fuck” and “I don’t want any of those dipshits to come wandering in here when the pigs start ramming their big fat pork sausages up their protesting do-gooder asses”) but I wanted to point it out given that you also describe a protester as “monkey man”.  While I can understand the analogy to a person being limber and swinging on the pole to being a monkey, I have to point out you’ve never given any reason to assume Nathan is bigoted (in fact he seems to agree with the protest at the end), but the term “monkey” is often used as a racial epithet.

I mention this because I was distracted by the usage of the term, since there was no tie in with his character being racist.

The actual street scene was a little confusing to me.  Was this protest one for gay rights (as George seems to imply after surveying the scene) or a proletariat solidarity march or political protest?  I suppose the actual intent of the march coud be irrelevant, but the scene seemed to me to erupt very suddenly without much buildup.

After reading this I was left wondering what Nathan gained from the experience.  He seemed to identify with the messge, yes, but he didn’t seem all that opposed to it at the beginning, so I didn’t get the impression of any personal growth here.

I’m not saying he needs any, but the quotes from the song seem to indicate message which I didn’t pick up on until I went back and re-read the song itself.  Personally speaking, I think I like the story better than the lyrics, and I would lose the lyrics all together throughout the story and give the characters words that feel more authentic to them.  By this I mean, to me it felt as though the characters were speaking, well, out of character just to get the lyrics said.

I like this piece as a “slice in time” scene, where a man is interrupted by life, takes a stroll, makes a witty observation, and goes about his day.  This seems to me to be what this piece is about.

I would also suggest either expanding George’s involvement or shrinking it drastically.  If Nathan dragged him out into the fray, his bigoted remarks and spoiled-middle-class-kid attitude would certainly add to some of the explosive tension in the crowd.  I imagine Nathan being utterly flabbergasted with George yelling to a hispanic man his burrito quote, then being drawn into a conflict trying to protect George.

I’d love to read  revision of this piece.  I am intrigued as to where this is headed.

Thanks for sharing!

cleverunderpressure avatar General Friend

June 01, 2008

cleverunderpressure

REVIEW QUALITY: 100.0%(1 vote ) personal info reviewer stats
cleverunderpressure reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

I. Loved. This. This is really right up my alley, this kind of fiction. It moves well, after a few sticky spots in the first two or three paragraphs – there it felt you were trying to force some words in there that you thought would look good, or sound good, some little above-average words – but sometimes the average words work just fine. After those few paragraphs you balanced the two very well – average words and a little vocabulary.

You also mixed up your verbs a lot, as in, you used a wide variety. However, sometimes it seems like you force the different verbs, juuust a little, such as ”...marching toward his still slumbering roommate sprawled…” Marching, to me, did not seem like a verb that slid into place quite as well as some others might have. I just realized you had a little bit of alliteration in that sentence, too, which is awesome – you did make use of some literary devices that aided the already-smooth flow of the story.

I LOVE that you united the “rich” (I’m not sure how rich Nathan is, but he’s certainly got enough money to live off of – also I loved that you used the name Nathan Hale, kudos!) and the poor in the end – I tried that in a short story once – it’s not nearly as good as this turned out. Of course, this wouldn’t exactly be perfectly realistic, this scenario, but mine was even less so – and it’s the hope that someday we CAN unite like this that counts, isn’t it?

You incorporated the song into the story, or rather, based a story off a song, beautifully. It didn’t seem like you were struggling to put the lyrics in at any point – using a protesting crowd to yell some of the lyrics was an excellent idea – and it was creative, very creative.

The only things would be proofreading. Keep messing with it. Keep taking out phrases and putting new ones in. Keep changing the words, fixing the grammar, the punctuation. There are some points, actually many, where I think if you tinkered with it, played with it, you could find some better usages of… the English language.

Overall I really, really enjoyed it. I’m looking forward to more things by you!

hypatia avatar General Friend

June 01, 2008

hypatia Prolific-icon-medium

personal info reviewer stats
hypatia reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

You have done a really good job of bringing the lyrics to life in a story. You have included all the key lines. The whole thing is well written and has a dream like quality to it throughout. It skirts reality in a very readable fashion.

I was confused about the meaning of this line. And come on, who do they think we’re fighting, the man?
“Where(’s) my wallet

bittersweetmemory avatar General Stranger

June 01, 2008

bittersweetmemory

personal info reviewer stats
bittersweetmemory reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

great job weaving lyrics into this brilliant short story. imaginative, “real”, great character developement, dialogue and story line.

the exchange between the homeless guy and george, is my favorite part… a kindness given cannot/should not be repaid with money!

bravo!

FrakKevin avatar General Stranger

June 01, 2008

FrakKevin

personal info reviewer stats
FrakKevin reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

I liked this and the part about his friend grabbing the controller was funny. How could he not be interested in something so huge going on outside lol. I thought this had a smart ending and your characters were real. Like having his friend kind of bash the gays show you weren’t trying to protect any specific group in your story. Plus even though Nathan didnt really care that much. I liked how he tried a little in the end. Anyway cool story.

Showing 1 - 8 of 8

Creator
Underscore79 avatar

Underscore79 Prolific-icon-medium

Age: 29
Loc: Lisle, IL
Gen: F
Last Login: November 18
Item Stats

GENERAL

8 Reviews 1 Comment
Version 1
Latest Activity: 2 months ago

REVIEW QUEUE

Appeared in Queue: 196 Times
Skipped: 9 Times
Large_criteria Ratings & Rankings
Tags

There are no tags for this item.