Poetry / America The Unbeautiful (Analysis)

My summer soldier has frozen to death
The ice of winter has crystallized his breath
My sunshine patriot has sadly run away
The thunder rolls in and rain dampens my day
My faith has grown weary of my future to come
I’ve lost both my soldiers and now I’m ready to run
I’m stuck in this crisis and I’ve no clue what to do
I can no longer stand proud to the red white and blue
Every day is a struggle to get out of bed
In my dreams you’re all to clear in my head
In the presence of company I fake a smile
Trying to be coy, hold back tears for a while
My heart strings pull to play a song
And I try to pretend that nothings wrong
And as the burning tears begin to fall
I’ll hold my head high and I will stand tall
Ignorant America; fighting fire with fire
You both lost your lives in a war of which we tire
And as days begin to pass, I feel incomplete
I want to fight this crisis but I must admit defeat
My soldiers lay manically in a grave six feet under
And I’m left here defenseless to weep for their slumber
Vulnerable and empty; my boys gone away
I’ve run out of rhymes, and I’ve nothing left to say

You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.

Reviews

Sort Reviews by  Newest |  Oldest |  Highest Quality |  Lowest Quality |  Newest Comments | 

 
CarsonLeonhardt avatar General Friend

October 06, 2008

CarsonLeonhardt

personal info reviewer stats
CarsonLeonhardt reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

well i love it, very different and the unnatural structure adds to its uniqueness, i would love to review the 2nd version to see how you changed up the last couple lines, unfortunately i have no clue how to do, let me know?

keep writing!

Carson Leonhardt

CharlesB avatar General Stranger

August 15, 2008

CharlesB

personal info reviewer stats
CharlesB reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Poetically, its alright. I’d like to see more structure to it. However, you developed your idea and emotions effectively, which was the best part, by far. On the subject, I am in the military myself, and find some of your ideas disagreeable. But alas, your sentiments towards this war and America/Americans is not up for the critiquing.

The poem could use a little work on its structure, maybe separate it into stanza’s, and keep a flowing and consistent rhyme theme.

sreed98 avatar General Stranger

July 30, 2008

sreed98

personal info reviewer stats
sreed98 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Very profound and well written about a terrible involvement America is in. Good job and keep up the good work.

JAs_jumper_cable avatar General Stranger

July 26, 2008

JAs_jumper_cable

personal info reviewer stats
JAs_jumper_cable reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

That piece was incredibly depressing, because it was so damn realistic. I am a sort of ‘chaotic neutral’ when it comes to answering the question ‘am I an American?’ This poem tugged at my heart and reminded me why I am against the war as well as the idea of war in general despite the rational behind it in any case. I felt for the narrator and wants to pull them into my arms. This piece successfully shook an emotional response out of me the reader, and will likely stick with me a while.

JamDive avatar General Stranger

July 07, 2008

JamDive

personal info reviewer stats
JamDive reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

It expresses your outrage over our national sins very well. There’s a few problem areas, such as:

My sunshine patriot has sadly run away
The thunder rolls in and rain dampens my day

Sunshine patriots are the ones who sneak home when things get rough. That is, they run away. You may want to slightly re-word that.

“In the presence of company I fake a smile
Trying to be coy, hold back tears for a while”

Coy usually has a flirtatious conotation, considera  substiturte word.

“My soldiers lay manically in a grave six feet under”

Manically doesn’t work well here.

“My faith has grown weary of my future to come” is a little clumsy; recommend you re-work that as well.

It is unclear what parts are directed at America as a whole, and which are directed at the two soldiers (presumably the authors’ children?) A little more structure/focus would help bring this together into a more harmonious piece. It’s a bit wordy in spots; try to tighten it up a bit where you can. For example “I can no longer stand proud to the red white and blue” is a good thought, but might be better expressed as “I no longer feel pride in the red, white and blue.”

But I hate the war too, and that emotion was communicated very well. Best of luck!

NathanD91 avatar General Stranger

July 07, 2008

NathanD91

personal info reviewer stats
NathanD91 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

This is a nice piece. IT’s one of those that there are going to be people who love it and agree with it, and those that hate it and don’t agree. I myself agree.  I understand.
“I want to fight this crisis but I must admit defeat
My soldiers lay manically in a grave six feet under”
This is probably one of the best lines I’ve read in poetry, and it’s one of my favorites in this poem. I really don’t see anything to say for you to change. I think it’s fine just the way it is.
But if anything I think You should take out the very last line. I kind of think there will be a better impact on people if you take it out. But it’s your choice.

Undone avatar General Stranger

July 07, 2008

Undone

personal info reviewer stats
Undone reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Wow! What a powerful piece it definitely pulled at my heartstrings. This is a sad piece and my heart goes out to you if this is your expierience. I feel it is written wonderfully and you brought me in with the power. However I do feel the last line takes away from the rest of the poem. You could take that last line out or maybe add another last line just my opinion. I really liked it though. Peace be with you and good luck. I really think this piece should be published.

Blue_Eyes avatar General Stranger

July 06, 2008

Blue_Eyes Prolific-icon-medium

personal info reviewer stats
Blue_Eyes reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

My main suggestion would be to focus on the meter/syllable count for each pair of rhyming lines. The meter is off throughout the poem, and this throws off the rhyme as well. I am also partial to punctuation. The last line of the piece has got to go! “I’ve run out of rhymes…” There has got to be something better that you could put in its place. The story/message is a good one, and it deserves a more fitting ending than what you currently have. I hope that this helps. :)

karrina avatar General Stranger

July 06, 2008

karrina

personal info reviewer stats
karrina reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

This is truely beautiful. I’m sure many Americans can relate to this. I’d love to see this in a book. You had one error in spelling but besides that I could find nothing else to fault. Amazing work. Please keep writing. I’ll have my friends review this for you as I’m sure they will love this as well.

KRIS84 avatar General Stranger

July 05, 2008

KRIS84

personal info reviewer stats
KRIS84 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100% of the Item

Beautiful peice…sry to hear of your losses.

Showing 1 - 10 of 10

Creator
Perfect_Shadow15 avatar

Perfect_Shadow15

Age: 16
Loc: Strandburg, SD
Gen: F
Last Login: November 14
Relevant Links
Item Stats

GENERAL

10 Reviews 15 Comments
Version 1
Latest Activity: 18 days ago

REVIEW QUEUE

Appeared in Queue: 0 Times
Skipped: 3 Times
Large_criteria Ratings & Rankings
Versions
Version 2
Version 1
Tags

There are no tags for this item.