jkazimer reviewed Version 1 -
Read 100% of the Item
From the top:
What would you do if a world … (Many agents suggest you don’t begin with a question. Now, I don’t think this is a bad one, maybe a bit long, but I think it works as a hook)
Calvin Thomas wasn’t always crazy. He began as a caring, gentle and loving brother to his sister, Eleanor, and cared for her after their parent’s mysterious death. (Too much information. Your goal is to provide the conflict and make me want to read your ms. This back story doesn’t do that. I like the wasn’t always crazy part, but the rest is useless to me as a cold reader) This was evident by the way he bought Christmas presents for her, had breakfast sent to her home every morning, made the telephone and electric payments every month before she or her husband had the chance to, and decided to create the formula MRX III to clean all the toxins polluting the waters of the world. (Same here. Get to the forula, its what this is about) Cal rushed his information to the EPA and his formula was widely received. The (lose THE) word spread quickly and all further research was to be backed by the government. Cal’s formula was created using mercury, and now he had to create the antidote to neutralize the toxins mercury created. (Two passive was sentence, try for a more active verb)
Eleanor Hargly, wife to Col.Roger Hargly and mother to her nine year old son, Kurt, had had enough of her obsessed, older brother Cal. (Again TMI, give us what’s important. You have like 5 sentences in a query to hook the agent, cut your blurb down to what’s really important) She’s tried e….
(At this point I feel like stopping, there’s just too much here for me to stay interested.)
Will Cal finish creating the antidote before his siter decides to move? Will he be able to control his anger if she leaves? Will Eleanor be proud of him for his accomplishments and want to remain near him? (Don’t end on a question. You started with one.) The Aquaguardians is a 500,000 word (HOLY CRAP, I hope this is a typo, because 500k is WAY TOO MANY words. Nobody, and I mean nobody will pick up a 500k manuscript from an unpublished author. That’s like 400k more than needed, and sort of explains the long drawn out explanation of the action) action novel (This is not a novel, a novel is a published work. This is a manuscript.) built around compelling characters (let the agent decide these are compelling characters.)set in a post-holocaust world where water--or more accurately, the one possesses it--reigns. It explores the lives and minds of the vilains and the heroes as they lose, love, suffer and grow in this quest to save the world. (Don’t tell me theme, let me read your ms and see for myself.)
Most query letters have a final paragraph about the author, like pub credits, platform, etc. And keep your query to 250 – 500 words. You’ll make the agent happier in the long run.
Good luck.
j