obamafu reviewed Version 5 -
Read 100% of the Item
Very good imagery.
It is relatively tight, but as you said, it came from a piece of ranting prose – and the remainder of this lengthy past still endures, somewhat.
Another general comment: your choice of words occasionally bristles with narrowly defined modern terms (not meanings, but terms), while you are speaking of events and artefacts in a broadly sweeping view. If the breadth of the word would be matched to the breadth of the picture, a resonance would makes the image stronger. Also, dated words (all the nano stuff, for example) create a dated (hence, short lived) construct.
Another general comment: words like “place”, “something” are dark gray, and they bleed away the color and the contrast from the surrounding words.
A few spots to clean/tune:
In the absence of punctuation (I think adding it in a few more spots, like this one, would not diminish your rhythm, but would help with deciphering the message), hard to see if it is “the spirits” “hung by rafters” or “the people” “hung by rafters” (one can figure it out, but this is a slowdown in reading the piece…).
“Instead, a single device offers peace
in place of fruitless study and thought.
It waits patiently, with dead circuits,
powerless.”
At this point, before reading the rest, the first two devices that come to mind are a TV and a flashlight (each with its own set of connotations). Which one would you rather focus on at this point in the poem – or which one would you rather have your reader would focus on?
“When suddenly, light stretches forth,
like walls that extend into heaven,
and each speck of light is a pore
on the face of some lowly creature.”
Here – again, the TV and the flashlight continue to fight for the place (“speck of light” would mean two different things – but the imagery is good in either one).
“and begin draining blood.” – maybe, “drawing blood”? This way, the action is more malevolent.
“Pixilation” – pixelation? Are we talking about pixies or pixels?
“a single image now glows bright,
green like the fumes off toxic waste
overflowing with helpful distraction.”
Which one is overflowing? The waste, the fumes, or the image?
“as far as the near-sighted eye perceives.
Blinking and humming without regard,
to the idiot masses stumbling below.” – perhaps, a comma after “perceives” with a non-capitalized “blinking”. I would – everywhere – bring capitalization in line with whatever unctuation you choose to keep.
“Millions make a pilgrimage to this idol
Lined up for miles with stones in hand” – again, “idol,/lined up”. Idol is not lined up, millions are.
“Single parents take each child,
more out of fear than curiosity,
and the children take their children,
never to be left out of the herd.” – “take” may be a bit neutral. Drag? Smother? Chain? Something with more defined action.
“lime and rust deposits” – comma after “deposits”.
“The fire underneath—a star,
constantly churning gases,
imploding until the fuel runs out.
Supernova, black-hole.” – an inconsistent description. Two sequential processes – one is expansion, puffing, gassing, running out of steam but getting denser, and another is the subsequent gravitational collapse – seem to get confused into one. Not many people would stumble over this one, though.
“Under the lid, pressure shifts
and releases in a piercing scream.
But no one dares take it off the burner,
not to be reactionary or childish.” – switch of a metaphor – from a star to a pot – was somewhat disappointing.
“All these components must be
a greater plan by an invisible creator;” – not a plan, but perhaps, “parts of a plan”. Components cannot be a plan.
“far below-average.” – “far below average.”
“that thought it was important,
By a reasonable chance.” – not really clear by itself.
“Thousands of nanopeople,
prematurely crushed
but left to go on living
as though death or god were at the door.” – I had a thought here which may have nothing to do with your intention… but I’ll share it anyway: “as though death of God was at the door.” Just a thought.
“rotted to dust” – “rotted to dust.”
“Black-winged angels fly in the windows
to put them out of their misery.” – to put whom out of misery? The angels themselves, or the windows, or someone else? If angels – maybe, “to give up their misery”?
“Hanging from the bottom of an airplane,
on America’s Stupidest People
Maiming Themselves,
twice a day by popular demand.” – this fragment stands all by itself. Maybe, it should be moved elsewhere within the poem, and anchored either by a few more words/lines or by a related non-general meaning.
“stepped on; as an activist group is formed” – “stepped on, as an activist group is formed”
“The tips of fingers transmit a signal;” – a sudden switch from overview of the world to a very personal closeup. A break in narration. It would help if this transition was facilitated.
“It has become non-compliant,” – “It has become non-compliant.”
“caused by intravenously amphetamines” – “caused by intravenous amphetamines” or “caused by intravenously fed amphetamines”
“Dizziness makes life a bit more bearable.” – why? There is no explanation, example, or justification for it.
“for a manic-depressive teenage girl.” – “for a manic-depressive teenage girl:” or a semi-colon.
“and die a quick death.” – not likely. Not a quick one. Need another word here. Flickering? Unnoticed? Flashed?
“With any luck she’ll go loudly,” – “With any luck, she’ll go loudly,”
But overall – good writing.