gradyperlson reviewed Version 1 -
Read 100%% of the Item
I thought this was a well-written and overall sharp poem. You did well in making this a visual poem, which, in my book, makes it a great one. I do have some critical points to make, though.
First, in the second line of the first stanza, I would get rid of the word “his”, as I feel it weakens the line. I tried reading instead “shoes are torn, ragged things” and thought it packed a little more emphasis to the shoes. It just seems to fit better, as you didn’t begin with “He paces…”
I would also scrap the word “cheap” in the last line of this stanza. It feels superfluous, as most motels these days are considered cheap.
In the last full stanza, I would take out the word “but” from the first line for the same reason as the earlier “his”. The “but” telegraphs the punch of “not today” , preparing the reader for it instead of just delivering. Remember that, in poetry, every word has to serve its purpose.
Finally, I would get rid of the ending “well, that’s what he gets for laughing.” This does not fit with this poem. It almost reads like a moral at the end of a fable and lightens the mood entirely too much. I think it is sufficient to end with the last full stanza and let the audience put the pieces together. It is fairly obvious that the bus drivers saw him as dangerous because he was homeless and laughing, seeming to be insane.
Otherwise, as I said before, I really liked this poem. Because I felt the changes I recommended were relatively minor, I think you deserve the 9 I scored this poem.