fred_kane reviewed Version 1 -
Read 100%% of the Item
I grade high, mainly because of age. At 14 you have an interseting way with voice and images. The third verse, though, strikes me as a first run that the writer felt sounded cool, and decided to let fly. It’s a broken metaphor that begins without explanation:”In the night, we cupped death in our hands,
comforted by her hot wings.
And she sighed, and flew into the sky,”
Is death a bird? A moth? A bat? A fairy/pixie? Whatever. I like that it leaves the reader to decide, but then there’s the following lines that state: death flies “like still oars watching drowning sailors cry out
for their rowboat drifting towards the shore.” I can see, where the writer might say to himself: “That sounds heavy! (and it does) Damn, I’m good!”
It’s just me, but I don’t get the connection between “flying death,” and “floating oars.” Please don’t take any of my Criticism as a put down against you or your talent. Like I stated earlier, at age 14, you ARE good!
I know that when I was younger, I would get lost in my writing (still do.) I would write in an euphoric state, and be in total amazement at what was flying from my fingers. When I revisited those writings at a later time, I’d say “Oh man, and I almost published that too.” Can you say “embarrassment?”