katelizabeth reviewed Version 1 -
Read 100%% of the Item
I really like the line, “more in need of rest than salvation.” I like the entire poem, actually – it achieves a quiet, somber tone perfect for the idea of waking up to churchbells. It’s so scrupulously punctuated that I was wondering why most of the first lines of the stanza are lacking commas when if this was written out as prose, they would need them.
I think there are several different ideas in this poem that pull it in more than one direction and it might benefit by cutting one or two of them. I think the Elsewhere stanza (although I love the “hush hush” at the beginning) isn’t really necessary because it pulls us away from the bed and the girl.
There are few lines I find awkward, like “the pillow I’m allergic to,” “so that soundwaves, at least/will speak her forgotten name.” I think they could worded a little more concisely or with a little bit better flow.
I love the “walking with left shoes in pairs” line. This is a lovely poem – I love the melancholy it evokes.