Journalism / Over the Top?

Without sounding too much like a gossip columnist, I must ask if the actions taken by ABC towards Grey Anatomy’s character Dr. Preston Burke, played by Isaiah Washington, is really all that necessary. If you are unaware of the situation, during a heated discussion with T.R. Knight, a homosexual actor who also stars on G.A., Washington used the word “faggot” in reference to Knight. As a result, ABC is now requiring that Washington “enter a program to examine why he would use such hateful words.” In other words, the network, under the pressures of many gay rights groups, is trying to save face and uphold their reputation.

What strikes me is that the consequences are as severe as they are. Having said that, let me say that I do not condone that sort of rhetoric nor do I dismiss Washington’s remarks as being completely overblown. I do, however, think it’s unnecessary for a person to be required to enter a treatment facility for uttering a word or making such a hateful reference towards someone.

Around the fifth grade of high school I was a chubby boy. I’m not sure if that had to do with the fact that I was largely inactive or because I was eating too much as a form of self comfort following my parent’s divorce. Nevertheless, I was fat. I was a likeable kid who had a quite a few friends so you’d think I would have had nothing to worry about; however, it was all too untrue. At that age, every physical shortcoming made me that much more of a target. All it took was an argument, or for someone to get mad or jealous of me, and I would be subjected to being called a fat ass or told that I had big ears. It was the human nature in the other kids to pick out my flaws, to uncover my weaknesses, to attempt to use those avenues of insecurities to strike the core of my being. And a lot of the times it worked.

I grew older and started playing junior high football. I lost weight and grew into my ears a little bit, but just as I started to think that my insecurities of my elementary years were covered up, new weaknesses started to surface. In the midst of anger, people would scour the surface to find those things, to exploit them, in attempts to break me down, to get to me, as they tried to once again feel in control, superior to me and the situation. Attribute it to their lack of self esteem, their other insecurities, or their lack of coping skills but the same was all true, people are human beings. Name calling is what we tend to do.

People are being criticized every day. That guy is a douchebag because he wears his shirts two sizes two small in an attempt to get girls to notice the muscles that have made him a slave to the gym. That girl is fat and ugly and only wears revealing clothing because her personality is not appealing enough for anyone to become engaged with. Is that really what’s going on? Who are we to know? What we do know is that in a world described by some scientists as “the survival of the fittest” people are always looking for advantages over others and the situations in their lives. If you get the people around you to believe that the girl in the corner is rude, stand-offish, and believes that she’s better than anyone else then you take away the allure of revealing her true self and the reasons behind her insecurities. As a result, you’ve created this desirable state for you and isolated that other person as someone that nobody should invest any interest in. Tally another point for self-esteem.

Why does that matter? Because in a world of reality, things are said that aren’t always meant. And in a life where it’s absolutely impossible to place judgment on someone’s heart and soul, it’s foolish to say that one sentence defines who you are, and the extensiveness of your beliefs.

Arguments happen all of the time. Incidents and situations commonly arise in workplaces that cross the lines of social acceptance. However, in Hollywood, it’s like living the world through a magnifying glass, a magnifying glass that is conformed by special interests and political correctness. Am I saying that Washington was right in what he said? Absolutely not. What I’m saying is that it’s petty and foolish for a married man and father of three to be require to enter a treatment facility for a one time verbal misnomer, particularly when there has been no documented evidence that this man (African American mind you) is either homophobic or suffers from any degree of anger management deficiencies. Otherwise, I think each individual person would have had to have spent some amount of time in a counseling facility, trying to figure out “why” they suffer from this thing called “human nature”.

p.s. I’m not even necessarily overly fond of Washington’s character in Grey’s Anatomy so I am in no way personally involved in defending him. It’s the concept.

You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.

Reviews

Sort Reviews by  Newest |  Oldest |  Highest Quality |  Lowest Quality |  Newest Comments | 

 
Chago avatar General Stranger

March 05, 2007

Chago

personal info reviewer stats
Chago reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item
This 134 word review has not been unlocked.
the_engaged_few avatar General Stranger

February 02, 2007

the_engaged_few

personal info reviewer stats
the_engaged_few reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item
This 299 word review has not been unlocked.
LoisLane907 avatar General Stranger

February 02, 2007

LoisLane907

personal info reviewer stats
LoisLane907 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item
This 75 word review has not been unlocked.
Incognito avatar General Stranger

February 01, 2007

Incognito

personal info reviewer stats
Incognito reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item
This 115 word review has not been unlocked.
Zanladar avatar General Stranger

February 01, 2007

Zanladar

personal info reviewer stats
Zanladar reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item
This 97 word review has not been unlocked.
fitterthanudad avatar General Stranger

February 01, 2007

fitterthanudad

personal info reviewer stats
fitterthanudad reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item

Dear Critic,

I don’t necessarily disagree with you, but I would point out two matters that you did not mention. Rather than attributing his “poor choice” of words to “human nature” (whatever that is!) I would have devoted my analysis to the network’s efforts to defend its gay demographic worth, I’m sure, a ton of money . Under the guise of being sensitive to “alternate lifestyles and gay rights”, the networks “mandates” sensitivity counseling, as if that is going to address the real issues.

On the other hand, the misspoken words are a reminder to “guard thy tongue”! Words once out, do have consequences-no matter whether you agree or disagree with the political underpinnings.

If anything, the offender may learn to be more discrete lest indiscretion cost him again more of his time because there is nothing more valuble than that!

Thank you,

Alan D Busch
www.thebookofben.blogspot.com

nelson1 avatar General Stranger

January 31, 2007

nelson1

personal info reviewer stats
nelson1 reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item

I get what you are saying, although i was badly bullied at school, even i’m guilty of the occasional name calling(normally in defence though). We are all human and there will always be tiffs and people can’t always get on together. Its kind of like the big brother situation in England, where a bit of bitching got out of control. and it actually got discussed by top politicians and created an international scandal. Ordinary people who put their foot in it are now being publicly hated to the point of fear in their own homes.

This journalism is very well written, i did not see any errors at all.

matty avatar General Stranger

January 31, 2007

matty

REVIEW QUALITY: 0.0%(1 vote ) personal info reviewer stats
matty reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item

How about the word Nigger?  How do you feel about that word?  It carries some weight, I myself use it sometimes if the person fits the definition.  As far as people’s cruelty toward one another that will never stop.  People also use their strenths to make up for shortcomings.  That is just reality man.  Nigger or not.

AndrewTH avatar General Friend

January 30, 2007

AndrewTH

personal info reviewer stats
AndrewTH reviewed Version 1 - Read 100%% of the Item

I’ve never seen Grey’s Anatomy nor was I really even aware of this whole kerfuffle until reading this.  A very well written piece, I agree with it on a lot of points.  I think we’ve become too concerned with “saving face” these days, and unfortunately the public seems to eat it up.

The old saw goes, “First impressions take 10 seconds to make and 10 years to change” or something like that.  Perhaps what annoys me the most is not so much the fact that people are judegmental or how judgemental some may be, it’s the fact that there has been such and industry built around it, which is probably one of the reasons that that this scenario has drawn such attention.  Realistically, how many times a day do we hear someone make a similar comment, or make one ourselves?

But such is the world we live in today.  As Edward Murrow said in his famous broadcast on McCarthy: “Cassius was right.  ’The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, but in ourselves.’”  I enjoyed reading this piece, especially the parts describing being picked on when you were younger.  I was (and perhaps still am) in much the same boat.  

I do think you could have left out the “disclaimer” in the second paragraph.  The rest of the piece made it clear (to me at least) that you don’t condone what was said, and it strikes me that it is somewhat antithetical to your overall critique of having to be politically correct and save face.

Showing 1 - 9 of 9

Creator
TheMayorOfOzunaville avatar

TheMayorOfOzunaville

Age: 27
Loc: Wichita Falls, TX
Gen: M
Last Login: November 08
Relevant Links
Item Stats

GENERAL

9 Reviews 1 Comment
Version 1
Latest Activity: about 1 year ago

REVIEW QUEUE

Appeared in Queue: 0 Times
Skipped: 0 Times
Large_criteria Ratings & Rankings
Tags

There are no tags for this item.