Cavol reviewed Version 1 -
Read 100%% of the Item
This is more of a character description, which is what I’ve been told about some of my work a few times. Ultimately, I’m indifferent to the character still. I understand he’s going though some things right now – the woman hurt him somehow and he hasn’t recovered but that’s not enough, I don’t think. Don’t get me wrong, I wasn’t bored. I was very interested in why his apartment was filthy and you gave a good reason, I think but that’ just…not enough.
I also thought the language was awkward and overstating in some places. For example:
Every day, she would clean the house so thoroughly just to avoid them. She made the bed every morning just in case one happened to be crawling around in the bed.
Instead, something like this:
She cleaned the apartment often and as a result, her fingers stripped from frequent exposure to bleach and other cleaning chemicals.
I also had an issue with the first sentence. For one, it’s long – too long; cut it up and get rid of one of those semicolons. The second one is used incorrectly. I don’t know that there’s on apartment on earth with one only bedroom but multiple bathrooms so why mention it only had one bathroom? If you wanted to say the apartment was small without saying, “the apartment is small” then just say he lived in a studio. You also don’t need, ”...than the living room” in the last sentence of that paragraph. Another thing – there is no such thing as just one cockroach. So the fact that he came home to see the same one is something I’d expect to see only in a Disney TV movie where the cockroach would talk and get in trouble with humans. That rules out naming it too.
Good luck, it’s a good start.