lizzette reviewed Version 3 -
Read 100%% of the Item
I hate to say this, but it’s really hard for me to believe that a 15 year old wrote this. So much for that.
The first paragraph is a little difficult to understand and needs a little clarification. The rest at times almost reads like a prose poem. At times excellent. Your sentence about the “grizzled jazz enthusiast who brushes off the dust from his tape deck” is exceptional.
If you are truly 15, you have an extraordinary future in store. And, of course, if you are 15, your sentence “I realized that time had never changed you” is absurd. Naturally we grow by leaps and bounds during puberty. But between 12 and 15? Come on now. Or the line “large contingent of friends bonded by time trickled down” Time? between 12 and 15? I don’t know. Over my years I might have lost my ability to understand some of the anguish of youth, but I don’t think so. Perhaps, for the sake of review, we need to forget that the age you’ve listed. But that’s difficult. If we can, and if we can assume that it’s not four years that have past, but a lifetime, the piece becomes much more meaningful. I wish I hadn’t seen that “age of the creator” part. Because, in truth, the piece is very very good.