Poetry / Too short to be great. Too long to be mediocre.

Give me a spoon! I’ll eat your soul. Then i’ll cook up your brain and feed it to dogs that rub their noses in grammar. Lets go Shakespear, Sing me a fucking sonnet! Serial killer style? I’ll leave that for the real sicko. I am kinda sick though, or so it goes. why? I write without thinking, and never think about writing. Fingers control me you see. They are my heart, lungs, and liver. The vital organs to the survival of me. Breath, puff and pass, No not the joint, the gift, and i got it from me, me, me. Now Tell me about the typos Mr. Critic…

You need to log in to urbis or create an urbis account to review this writing.

Reviews

Sort Reviews by  Newest |  Oldest |  Highest Quality |  Lowest Quality |  Newest Comments | 

 
horse avatar General Stranger

January 08, 2008

horse

personal info reviewer stats
horse reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

There are times when a rant is warranted…and effective. I’m not certain what started this one, but I suppose that I can guess. This rant has some moments. In all though, this is too disjointed to actually hit home. It just comes off as angry and a bit silly in the end.

Willow_Wren avatar General Stranger

January 08, 2008

Willow_Wren

personal info reviewer stats
Willow_Wren reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

I like the first line then it starts to fall apart. This is a parody I take it on something, Urbis reviews, writing poetry, or just tongue-in-cheek sarcasm. I sense hostility here and not sure who or what it is directed at. As a prose poem it’s rather self-centered and it’s all telling, well, that’s just my take, not sure where this poem is going.

tstone avatar General Friend

January 08, 2008

tstone

personal info reviewer stats
tstone reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

“Fingers control me you see. They are my heart, lungs, and liver.”  i like this line – good description of the urge to create and its impulsive demands,  burning and vital.  i would love to see you take this rawness, (for lack of a better word,) into a narrative form, as in a short story.  not a suggestion for this particular work, i like it as it is… but possibly another direction to consider in the future.  henry miller’s ‘tropic of cancer’ comes to mind as an example.

evath avatar General Stranger

January 08, 2008

evath

personal info reviewer stats
evath reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

As opposed to the last one, which I didn’t care for
as it read like the menu at a sex-food restaurant,
this one here has soul, passion and fire.
good for poetry.
not namby-pamby.
and I only saw one typo.
and that was Shakespeare was spelled wrong ;-)
but you asked for it, so you got it.
I think this is definitely a thumbs up!

CourtshipLives avatar General Stranger

January 07, 2008

CourtshipLives

personal info reviewer stats
CourtshipLives reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

i was going to comment about your lack of structure but then i realized that is the point of your poem, and that you’re rather genius for thinking that. this is so true. there are a bunch of pretentious, self-righteous, purist bastards that menstruate when you disregard the textbook recommended number of syllables or lines or stanzas or what-have-you. i say fuck em. i have respect for most artforms and the artists that coined them but if you need someone’s rules to tell you how to express yourself, you obviously have no artistic worth, let alone any individuality whatsoever. forget the rules and just write the real shit that just flows out of your veins. great poetic rant. right on, man.  

tentoes avatar General Stranger

January 07, 2008

tentoes

personal info reviewer stats
tentoes reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

Wow, fascinating piece! I’m so happy to have read it. Clearly, you challenge those critics/dogs who consume your work and then belch big nasty clouds of advice on punctuation and spelling, while never considering the true flavor of what they have just read. For the record, I enjoyed the meal.

Because you mention it almost as a challenge, I will NOT answer any urge I might have to give technical critique.  I have to say though, that there are many very talented and experienced writers and publishers here, whose advice should be at least chewed, even if not swallowed. I always see critique of my work like reading an instruction manual.  I retain only what might apply in future to the work at hand, and forget the rest.

Thanks for this one. I’ll be looking forward to reading, (sans critique), more of your work.

smiles,
toes

OfTrepidation avatar General Stranger

January 07, 2008

OfTrepidation

personal info reviewer stats
OfTrepidation reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

honestly, i love typos. when i write, my i’s are pretty much always lower case. yes, i know it is not “correct” but thats me.

Blue_Eyes avatar General Stranger

January 07, 2008

Blue_Eyes Prolific-icon-medium

personal info reviewer stats
Blue_Eyes reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

I am sorry, I just was not feeling this one much at all. There are some good ideas here, but they are not fully realized, from my perspective. Perhaps you should put more thought into your writing.

Maud avatar General Stranger

January 07, 2008

Maud

personal info reviewer stats
Maud reviewed Version 3 - Read 100% of the Item

Interesting piece. Particularily like the line…feed it to the dogs that rub their noses in grammar. So, tell me if I got the message.

Are these the rantings of an angry non-conformist poet who is compelled to write, but only on his own terms. Writing is, in fact, central to his very existence. I use the pronoun his because of the amount of violence embedded within the poem—this is usually a guy thing (if you’ll forgive the sterotype. He is asking for criticsm, but at the same time rejecting and mocking it before it’s given.

There may be a limited market for works of this nature, but I liked it for some reason. Maybe it’s the rebellious tone.

Showing 1 - 9 of 9

Creator
word4wisdom avatar

word4wisdom

Age: 21
Loc: NY, NY
Gen: M
Last Login: September 24
Relevant Links
Item Stats

GENERAL

9 Reviews 14 Comments
Version 3
Latest Activity: 10 months ago

REVIEW QUEUE

Appeared in Queue: 129 Times
Skipped: 4 Times
Large_criteria Ratings & Rankings
Versions
Version 3
Version 2 (Deleted) Version 1 (Deleted)
Tags

There are no tags for this item.